AMS & Associates, Inc. For All Your Accounting Needs.

Business Taxes

LLC vs. S Corporation: What's the Difference?

An LLC is a legal structure and an S corporation is a federal tax classification. Here is how the two relate, and what to consider before making an S corporation election.

4 min read Updated

"Should I be an LLC or an S corporation?" is one of the most common questions new business owners ask. It is also a question built on a misunderstanding, because the two are not alternatives. One is a legal structure. The other is a way of being taxed. A business can be both at once.

An LLC is a legal entity

A limited liability company is created under state law. In Minnesota, that means filing articles of organization with the Secretary of State. Once formed, the LLC is legally separate from its owners, who are called members. The principal reason people form one is to keep the business's debts and legal claims separate from their personal assets.

That is a legal matter. It tells you nothing yet about how the business is taxed.

S corporation status is a tax classification

"S corporation" refers to Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code. It is a federal tax status, not a kind of company. You cannot form an S corporation at the Secretary of State's office. A business that already exists as a corporation or an LLC asks the IRS to tax it under those rules, generally by filing Form 2553.

To be eligible, a business must meet certain requirements. Among them, it can have no more than 100 shareholders, its shareholders generally must be individuals who are U.S. citizens or residents (certain trusts and estates also qualify), and it can have only one class of stock.

So an eligible LLC can elect S corporation taxation. When it does, it remains an LLC under state law. Only its federal tax treatment changes.

How an LLC is taxed by default

If an LLC makes no election, the IRS applies default rules based on the number of owners.

A single-member LLC is disregarded for income tax purposes. The owner reports the business's income and expenses on Schedule C of a personal return, exactly as a sole proprietor would, and pays self-employment tax on the net earnings.

A multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership. It files Form 1065, and each member receives a Schedule K-1 reporting their share of the income. Members who are active in the business generally pay self-employment tax on their share.

In both cases, forming the LLC did not change the owner's tax bill. This surprises many people who formed an LLC expecting a tax benefit.

What changes with an S corporation election

An LLC taxed as an S corporation files Form 1120-S. Its profit still passes through to the owners' personal returns, so the business itself generally does not pay federal income tax.

The significant change is in how an owner who works in the business is paid. That owner becomes a shareholder-employee and must receive reasonable compensation for the services they perform, paid as wages through payroll. Those wages are subject to income tax withholding and to Social Security and Medicare taxes, just like any employee's. Profit beyond that compensation can be distributed to the owner, and distributions are not subject to self-employment tax.

Reasonable compensation is not optional and it is not whatever the owner would like it to be. The IRS expects it to reflect what the business would pay someone else to do the same work. Paying an unreasonably low salary in order to take more in distributions is a well-known examination issue.

The costs that come with the election

The election adds obligations that a sole proprietor or default LLC does not have:

  • Running payroll for the owner, with regular tax deposits
  • Quarterly Form 941 filings and an annual Form 940
  • Minnesota withholding and unemployment insurance filings
  • A W-2 for the owner each year
  • A separate business tax return, Form 1120-S, due a month earlier than individual returns
  • Careful records separating wages, distributions and reimbursements

Each of these takes time and usually costs money. For a business with modest profit, the added cost and effort can outweigh any benefit. For a business with higher, steadier profit, the calculation may come out differently. There is no income level at which the election automatically makes sense, and anyone who names one without looking at your numbers is guessing.

What the election does not do

S corporation status does not itself create legal liability protection. Whatever protection the owner has comes from the underlying LLC or corporation and from operating it properly. A sole proprietor cannot gain liability protection by making a tax election, because there is no entity to make it.

It also does not make personal expenses deductible, and it does not eliminate income tax on the profit that passes through to the owner.

No structure is best for every business

A default LLC is simple and inexpensive to maintain. An S corporation election can change how an owner's earnings are taxed, at the price of payroll and additional filings. Which is appropriate depends on the business's profit, how consistent that profit is, the owner's role, and the owner's plans.

We can walk through the accounting and tax side of that comparison with you as part of our business consulting work. Questions about legal liability and the formation documents themselves should go to an attorney.

Contact our office

Tell us what you need help with. We will let you know how we can assist and what information to bring.